Introduction: Ranked-choice voting (RCV) is an electoral reform allowing voters to rank candidates in order of preference, ensuring winners have broad support. Maine and Alaska are pioneering states in adopting RCV statewide, using it to enhance voter choice and improve election dynamics. This report outlines how RCV was adopted in these states, its implementation, and voter perceptions based on surveys and polling.
History and Adoption of RCV in Maine: Maine became the first U.S. state to adopt RCV statewide after a citizen-led referendum in November 2016. The measure passed narrowly, with 52% voting in favor. Advocates cited concerns about plurality winners in crowded races as a primary motivation. Legislative and judicial challenges followed, but RCV was preserved through a second referendum in 2018, reaffirming public support. Since then, RCV has been used in federal elections and primaries for state and congressional offices .
RCV’s implementation was historic; in 2018, Maine conducted the first congressional election using RCV, which led to the election of Jared Golden in the 2nd Congressional District. The process demonstrated how RCV could reshape competitive dynamics, particularly in politically divided regions .
History and Adoption of RCV in Alaska: Alaska adopted RCV in November 2020 through Ballot Measure 2, which combined RCV with a nonpartisan top-four primary system. The measure passed with 50.55% approval. Proponents argued that RCV would reduce partisan polarization and empower voters to express nuanced preferences. Alaska’s first RCV election was held in 2022, with significant public and media attention. Voters elected Mary Peltola to the U.S. House, a result showcasing RCV’s impact in providing broader electoral competition .
Implementation Challenges and Adaptations: Both Maine and Alaska faced modest challenges in implementing RCV, centering primarily around public education campaigns to familiarize voters with the system. Maine developed a robust public outreach effort, distributing clear materials explaining the RCV process. Similarly, Alaska used a combination of direct mailers, online tutorials, and community events to inform voters.
Voter Satisfaction and Survey Data: Surveys and exit polls indicate high voter satisfaction with RCV in both states:
- Ease of Use: In Maine’s 2022 elections, 82% of voters found RCV easy to use. Similarly, in Alaska, 85% reported no difficulty ranking candidates.
- Understanding: Surveys in Alaska showed 77% of voters understood RCV well, with support for its continuation rising after the first election cycle.
- Desire for Continuation: Polling revealed broad approval for keeping RCV. In Maine, 57% supported RCV after multiple election cycles, while Alaska’s voters increasingly appreciated the system’s ability to reflect diverse preferences .
Impact on Elections: RCV has demonstrated measurable effects:
• Increased Competition: Both states saw more candidates participate in elections without fear of vote-splitting.
• Voter Engagement: Surveys show voters felt their votes “mattered more” under RCV. In Alaska, 60% believed the 2022 elections were more competitive than previous ones .
Conclusion: Ranked-choice voting in Maine and Alaska exemplifies a growing trend toward electoral innovation aimed at increasing fairness and voter empowerment. Both states have overcome challenges to implement RCV effectively, earning strong public support. Continued education and transparent processes will be essential to sustaining this reform.
For further reading, visit:
RCV America 
Leave a comment